We are available to meet with clients in Champaign-Urbana area by appointment.
Contact Us

Estate Planning and Elder Law Attorney | Dent Coulson Elder Law

Get Help Right Away

Call Today: 618-632-7000 or 217-330-5500

or Send us an email

  • Home
  • Our Services
    • Alzheimer’s Planning
    • Asset Preservation Planning
    • Estate Planning
    • Medicaid Eligibility
    • Special Needs Planning
    • Trust and Estate Administration
    • VA Benefits Planning
  • News & Videos
    • Video Series
      • Coronavirus Preparedness
      • Asset Preservation Planning
      • Common Estate Planning Mistakes
      • Dealing With Alzheimer’s
      • Financial Exploitation of Elders
      • Handling Difficult Conversations with Seniors
      • Married Couples and Medicaid
      • Medicaid Application Process
      • Medicaid Look-Back Rule and Transfer Penalties
      • Nursing Home Admission and Care
      • Veterans Pension Benefits
      • What You Can and Can’t Keep with Medicaid
    • Weekly Newsletter
    • The Elder Law Minute
  • Alzheimer’s Guide
  • Presentations
    • Health Care Power of Attorney
  • Hear From Our Clients
    • Testimonials
    • Share Your Experience
  • About
    • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
    • Partners & Resources
    • About Our Fees
    • COVID-19 Policies
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
    • Email Us
    • Find Our Offices
    • Refer a Friend
  • DCEL Blog

Shield or Sword? Illinois Law to Protect Seniors

Proposed Illinois Law Seeks to Protect Seniors from Caregivers Who Would Take Advantage of Them



Illinois Senate Bill 1048 recently passed both Houses of the Illinois General Assembly and was sent to the Governor on June 27, 2014. The bill that is expected to be signed by Governor Quinn amends the Probate Act of 1975 by adding a new “Presumptively Void Transfers” Article to the Act which would apply to “transfer instruments” (which includes a will, living trust, beneficiary designation or other means by which someone might inherit property from a person who dies) that are signed starting January 1, 2015.

The new law provides that all gifts of property to caregivers effective on an elderly person’s death are presumed void if the amount given to the caregiver is greater than $20,000. The intent and purpose behind the law is to protect seniors and their families from caregivers who would try to endear themselves to the senior for the purpose of influencing them to make gifts to the caregiver by their will or other estate planning instruments.

The law defines a “caregiver” as a person who voluntarily (without being paid), or in exchange for compensation (being paid), has assumed responsibility for all or a portion of the care of another person who needs assistance with activities of daily living. The law’s definition of caregiver does not include a family member of the person receiving assistance. As such, it does not apply in the case of gifts or bequests to family member caregivers.

A caregiver who is entitled to or is otherwise deserving can still receive a gift if they can either show that their share under the transfer instrument is not greater than the share of the elder’s estate that they would already be entitled to prior to becoming the caregiver, or establish under a high burden of proof that the gifts or transfers made to them were not the product of fraud, duress, or undue influence.

The law provides that a caregiver who tries unsuccessfully to overcome a presumption that a gift is void shall bear the costs of the proceedings, including, without limitation, reasonable attorney’s fees. Additionally, the law creates a civil remedy by which the family of a senior can recover any gift to a caregiver that was improper, but the challenge must be filed within two years of the date of the senior’s death.

Hopefully, with the passage of Senate Bill 1048, caregivers whose motive is to take advantage of seniors will not be able to get away with it, at least in Illinois. If and to the extent that the law proceeds in protecting seniors from those “wolves in sheep’s clothing,” it will have accomplished a substantial good.

On the other hand, it’s also easy to imagine a situation in which the operation of the law could produce unfortunate and unintended results. For example, consider the situation of a widowed or single person who has received little or no care or support from family members (in the case of a single elder without children, it’s easily possible that the nearest relatives could be nieces and nephews, or even cousins, with whom the elder has never had a close relationship), but who has enjoyed a close relationship with a companion or lifelong close friend who has stood by his or her side and provided loving care and comfort over the course of a prolonged illness. If that person then signs a will or any other type of document that leaves more than $20,000 to that companion or friend, it would be a presumptively void transfer.

In that situation, the law may not operate as a shield protecting the close family, but rather as a sword that could be wielded by more distant relatives interested in making sure that they inherit as much as possible, even if that is clearly not what the elder would have intended. The law’s sanctions against the companion or friend for supporting what their companion or friend did for them are such that it might be difficult for many of them to stand their ground, since they would face the prospect of having to (a) pay both sides’ attorneys’ fees for what could be very expensive litigation, and (b) getting sued for any gifts made to them during the companion or friend’s lifetime.

As a result, the law should also have the effect of imposing a burden on elders who, for what could be very good and understandable reasons, want to choose in their estate plans to favor a companion or friend who has cared for them in the later stages in their lives. Seniors need to be aware of the law, and to proceed with an awareness that, in any “he said, she said” lawsuit brought after their death, the one person whom a judge or jury would most want to hear from in determining whether the presumption that their intended transfer is void has been successfully overcome is them.

Our recommendation to clients in that situation will be that they have us interview them, confidentially but in the presence of a “videographer” (a court reporter with a video camera), regarding the facts and circumstances that led them to their decision to favor the companion or friend who has cared from them. That “straight from the horse’s mouth” testimony, if properly legally preserved, will provide the best assurance that their intentions will, in fact, be carried out.

Veterans Benefits O'Fallon ILFor Immediate Help

If you or a loved one needs immediate help with a planning matter or legal issue, please contact us, and we will get back to you promptly.

774 Sunset Blvd Suite 200
O'Fallon, IL 62269
IL: (618) 632-7000
MO: (314) 567-9292

1901 South Fourth Street,
Suite 211, Effingham, IL 62401
(217) 330-5500

Fax: (618) 632-7333

Office Hours
Monday - Thursday
8:30 am - 12:00 pm
1:00 pm - 4:00 pm
Friday
8:30 am - 12:00 pm

Champaign-Urbana by appointment

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Join us for a FREE Workshop

 

Free WorkshopsIf you have reached age 65, there's about a 45% chance that you will eventually need long-term care.

Join us for one of our highly informative and FREE workshops and find out how you can protect your family's hard-earned life savings.

Visit Free Workshops for more information.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our free weekly Newsletter and receive the latest news, updates and videos straight to your inbox!

Recent Posts

  • Knowing What You Own and How You Own It
  • Estate Planning as the First Step for Medicaid Planning
  • Guardianships: The More You Know
  • Medicaid Pre-Planning vs Emergency Medicaid Planning
  • How Should I Prepare for a Move into Long Term Care?

More News & Videos

  • Alzheimer's Planning (85)
  • Asset Preservation Planning (150)
  • Coronavirus Preparedness Series (9)
  • Coulson Elder Law (11)
  • DCEL Blog (1)
  • Document Signing (15)
  • Elder Law Minute Video (446)
  • Estate Planning (193)
  • Health Care Planning/Medicare (140)
  • Medicaid Eligibility (202)
  • News & Videos (490)
  • Special Needs Planning (48)
  • Trust Administration (14)
  • Veterans Benefits (51)

Front office building of Coulson Elder Law

Front office building of Coulson Elder Law

  • Directions to our office locations
  • Send us an email
  • About Us
  • News and Videos
  • Weekly Newsletter
  • Brochures
  • Presentations
  • Hear From Our Clients
  • Partners & Resources
  • Legal Disclaimer

Copyright © 2025 · Wesley J. Coulson | Dent Coulson Elder Law, LLC